cosmo111687's Action Comics #1 - Superman Versus the City of Tomorrow review

    Avatar image for cosmo111687

    More Powerful Than A Locomotive

    I would throw myself underneath the wheels of any train of thought

    Roaming the rails or sailing through the roadways of your brain.

    If I could bring a light to shine upon the dark and disobey

    The night so young, but I still say we're too old for cliches.

    Oh, and I can only dream of he dreams we'd share if you were so inclined.

    I would love to be the one to open up your mind.

    - Jeff Tweedy, "Open Up Your Mind"

    Story/Writing

    Perfect. This issue does everything that is needed for a retelling of the Superman tale in an inventive approach that doesn't make anything feel like tired or hackneyed. Grant Morrison wishes to not just glorify Superman from the start, but to test him and from that testing, rebuild him as an even stronger character than before. And within the pages of the first issue, that not only means testing him to see if he truly is faster than a speeding bullet, able to leap tall buildings in a single bound, and yes (in a climatic and heart-stirring ending) prove whither or not he is more powerful than a locomotive, but also testing his morals by showing his brashness and naivety in the young years of his career. There's something pure here in Grant Morrison's writing. And in a DC Universe that is increasingly gravitating towards horror, it's a relief to find an issue that is just filled with humor and joy.

    Art

    I've heard a lot of criticism of Rags Morales' art on this issue, but I have to disagree with his detractors. I think that he did a wonderful job of imbuing this issue with a great deal of joy. With the exception of a few cases of "fishy-eyes", where the eyes would go off-center from time to time, I felt that his draftsmen-ship was spot on and the pacing of scene to scene, from panel to panel, was just perfect. Although, knowing how Grant Morrison likes to work (he typically fills notebooks with pages after pages of how pre-visualizations of the comic before writing the script, and will sometimes send them to the artist for reference), I can't be sure how much of the direction was Rags Morales and how much of it was Grant Morrison. Even still, Morales did a wonderful job and deserves credit. However, he shouldn't be given the whole credit here. Rick Bryant's inks and Brad Anderson's colors were phenomenal. Bryant's subtle cross-hatching gave the issue a very early 20th century illustrative touch that instantly made it feel classic while Anderson's colours gave it the glisten and high-polish of something strictly 21st century (giving it a strong resemblance to the lens flares in the new Star Trek film.)

    A Bit of Speculation

    I wonder what it is that Luthor sees coming towards us, past the orbit of Neptune...

    Final Rating - 5/5

    Other reviews for Action Comics #1 - Superman Versus the City of Tomorrow

      A New Golden Age 0

      I’ve waited a long time for this issue. I’ve engaged in a lot of smack talk leading up to it. I couldn’t be more thrilled with how Grant Morrison’s Action Comics #1 actually turned out. This is the Golden Age version of Superman perfectly updated for our modern world. Superman is acting as a social crusader for an economy in recession just as the first version of Superman did for the 1930’s depression. He really shows himself to be the “Champion of the Oppressed” once again in one memorable scen...

      14 out of 14 found this review helpful.

      Superman going back to his roots 0

          Cover I picked this issue at whim. I always liked Superman but I never could get into Action Comics or his own series because there were so many issues and I never knew where to start. But now with the reboot happening I took my chances and picked up this issue because I saw that I would not be lost because on the cover it says issue 1. I also really like Superman’s costume for the cover. It is different from the usual Superman costume but not drastically different. I think jeans look good ...

      12 out of 12 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.